ONLINE FIRST
published on October 31, 2018
Carole M. Cusack
https://doi.org/10.5840/jrv2018103055
Self-Murder, Sin, and Crime: Religion and Suicide in the Middle Ages
From around 1000 CE, evidence for suicide in the West becomes more plentiful. Sources include chronicles, legal records, saints¡¯ lives, and other religious texts. Motivations for suicide are familiar: ¡°bereavement, poverty, and sudden disgrace or dismissal from a high post,¡± and some ¡°suicides without obvious external motive¡± which clerics focused on, as they viewed acedia (apathy) as demonic (Alexander Murray, ¡°Suicide in the Middle Ages,¡± 3). Among Christian objections to suicide are that it deprived lords of their property, it offended against humanity, it was linked to Judas¡¯s betrayal of Jesus, and it violated the commandment ¡°You shall not kill¡± (Exodus 20: 13). Religious aspects of suicide motivations and punishments are here examined in terms of victims and perpetrators. ?mile Durkheim¡¯s sociology, which foregrounds anomie, dialogues with medieval historians to argue that suicide as a sin against God outweighed secular ideas of crime, and that claims of lenience toward women and those driven to self-murder are overstated.